Looking at Life Through an Apologetics Lens

Looking at Life Through an Apologetics Lens

I realized recently that I can’t help looking at everything in life, and I mean every single thing, through an apologetics lens. What do I mean by that? I mean that in all things I see and read and hear and experience, every encounter I have in our material world, I see our infinite, eternal, Creator, Savior God. All of it, every single thing, shouts out to me, Christianity is The Truth! God is real! I’ve known this for some time given I raised our three children this way, but it struck me recently how all pervasive this mindset is in my life, like 24/7/365 pervasive, every second of every minute of every hour of every day.

Looking back through my life this was either something I was born with or it developed early on because it was the reason I embraced Evangelical Christianity in the first place. When I was presented the biblical case for the gospel and the assurance of our salvation in Christ, I accepted it immediately, but I struggled with deciding if I really wanted to go all in and give myself fully to God. The way I thought about it was, if this is real, if God is actually there and it’s all true, then he deserves my all. Being educated in a public school, which I’m still a little bitter about, I never got to study logic, but even so, I knew Christianity was either true or it was not, thus I had to decide if I believed it was true. If it was, then there was no turning back, and I was all in. This took a number of months because I knew it was an all-consuming commitment, but if true I could do nothing else.

I was then a very green 18 years old, naïve and ignorant, as are all teenagers, and thought I had it all figured out, but I discovered in due course that I was on a journey of infinite miles, and I was only taking the first step. It wasn’t long into the journey when I discovered Francis Schaeffer’s, The God Who Is There, and that was my introduction to apologetics. Instead of the Pietistic and Platonic dualism of spiritual and material, heavenly and earthly I was born-again into, I started to see everything from a Christian perspective, a Christian worldview. I learned that life only made sense interpreting it from that perspective, seeing it all come into focus through the Christian lens of Scripture. I could not only believe Christianity was true, but now I began to see all of life as evidence for that claim. What we believe about God or religion doesn’t make it true or not, contrary to what most people today tend to think.

How Everything Reveals God
As I grew in my knowledge in many areas, theology, apologetics, history, philosophy, sociology, etc., my conviction that everything proclaimed God’s reality and glory grew. I couldn’t help seeing everything this way. I recently read Augustine’s Confessions, and he captured this thought wonderfully speaking about beauty:

All things are beautiful because You made them but You are inexpressibly more beautiful, who made all things.

The only reason beauty exists, and that we know it and appreciate it, is because God is beauty himself, and we can know something of him through it. This reminds me of one of those priceless moments you have with your kids when they are growing up. My youngest, Dominic, and I were on the way to church alone for some reason, and I was as I usually did at the time listening to some apologetics talk on my little MP3 player. On the walk toward the church Dominic says to me, as a young teenager would, “Dad, I think I like music more than apologetics,” and I replied, “Dude, music is apologetics!” And I said it robustly and demonstratively, as I am wont to do. I’m sure I expounded on that a bit, probably with thoughts I’m expressing in this piece.

One of the reasons I had confidence my children would never abandon the faith when they grew up was because I consistently conveyed to them life through an apologetics lens. That meant everything in life had to be defined in one way or the other, either as a product of God’s existence, or a product of chance. I would mock the latter idea with my kids when we would see a beautiful sunset, for example, and exclaim, “Praise Chance!” I didn’t have to prove God was the creator of such beauty; it was obvious.

I came to call this either/or idea, the consideration of the alternative. It’s important to understand the temptation of chance as “Creator” because the temptation of modern people in the West is secularism and the Darwinian view of “nature.” I put that in quotation marks because when we use the word “nature” as opposed to creation, we allow the assumption to exist underneath that it is in fact a product of chance, that everything exists as a result of unguided material processes over a very long period of time. I don’t use the word “nature” anymore because we don’t live in a Christian culture, but always refer to the material world as what it is, creation. We learn from Paul why this is so important:

20 For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that people are without excuse.

Today, the assumptions of secularism are the lenses through which we view the material world, and they can affect us if we’re not careful. I have two examples of how this happens.

Some years ago when we lived in Illinois, I went to lunch with some guys from our church. They were talking about this great Yankees outfielder, and his ability at the crack of the ball on the bat to go to exactly where the ball would be at the exact right time. They were saying how amazing it is to watch that, and it is. Then I said, “And imagine the God who created a creature that can do that!” They kind of looked at me strangely for a split second, not that they wouldn’t of course agree with that, but their focus was on a great athlete. They primarily saw the guy and his talent and skill more than they saw God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature. I can’t help always  seeing the former in the latter.

I’m not letting myself off the hook either. It didn’t occur to me until later in life that there is no distinction between the natural and the supernatural. That’s how we, especially in a secular culture, tend to see things. I realized that as I was writing my first book, The Persuasive Christian Parent. In God in the Dock, C.S. Lewis pointed out that Mary’s conception by the Holy Spirit was no more miraculous than any woman’s conceiving. Is not a new being’s creation utterly miraculous? Are we really supposed to believe the process of creating a new life is solely “natural”? No divine assistance required? I remember vividly when my stubborn firstborn, a daughter, finally decided to come out of the womb after an excruciatingly long time (all that waiting, and waiting, and waiting), my first thought through all the blubbering and tears was, “There is a God!” And I have a similar response when I look at any being, human or not, but also when I contemplate a seed of any kind. Within it are Aristotle’s four causes, the material, formal, efficient, and final cause all rolled up into one! A huge oak tree exists in a little acorn. Is that not a miracle?

When I talk about chance as our “creator,” it’s not that we’re told this, but it is assumed everywhere we go, in everything we see or hear. A perfectly innocuous example comes from a golf tournament we had on the TV. The first PGA tournaments of the year are always in Hawaii, and they broadcast the beauty and grandeur of the islands. The commentators, watching a large gray whale frolicking in the sea, remarked how beautiful this magnificent creature was, how majestic and awesome a sight. However, what they couldn’t say was how incredible and awesome must be the God who created that whale—the God who thought up the concept of a whale in the first place, and water, and oceans, and gravity, and an earth and moon, and human beings who could be blown away by the experience of it! A professional announcer today wouldn’t think of injecting “religion” into such an environment. At times like that I yell at the TV and say something like, “What about the God who created it!”

In apologetics this is called “the design inference.” Everything that exists is a reflection of the person or being who designed it. We see this in all things human beings create, and in everything God created and creates, like each one of us! My goal with our children was to continually build into into their consciousness a God infused counter‑assumption to the secular, materialist assumptions of the day. If we see God’s majesty and power and his creative energy infusing all things, it’s easy and natural to pass that on to our children. It’s a way of life, and way of seeing things you can’t just un-see. Once the idea gets ingrained in them, they will see atheist claims as manifestly implausible for the rest of their lives, and now that they are adults, two with children of their own, I can attest that it works exceedingly well.

Transformation as Apologetic
Two things happened in my life that eventually led to the title of this section, that transformation, simply put, change from bad to good, both in people’s lives and in society, is evidence of God’s reality and the truth of Christianity. Back in early 2020 I read a book by Tom Holland called Dominion: How the Christian Revolution Remade the Modern World. Published in 2019, the book’s significance is hard to overestimate because it blew up secular assumptions about the modern world, and why it exists. Because of the Enlightenment, Western cultural elites in their war against Christianity needed to explain away Christianity’s beneficial influence on the development of the modern world. To them because of the wars of religion, blamed on Christianity, secularism needed to take its place as the God-less alternative to how western society and culture had developed and should be run. Holland’s book challenged all their explanations and their secular anti-Christian assumptions.

A non-Christian, Holland’s journey to this conviction is an interesting one. He grew up idolizing the ancient pagan world, but over time realized the assumptions and principles he took for granted

about how a society should properly be organized, and the principles that it should uphold—were not bred of classical antiquity, still less of ‘human nature’, but very distinctively of that civilization’s Christian past. So profound has been the impact of Christianity on the development of Western civilization that it has come to be hidden from view.

And taken for granted. Though hidden, the assumptions and principles are nonetheless Christian. The days of the loud and proud arrogant atheists of the early 21st century who proclaimed that “religion poisons everything,” in the subtitle of the late Christopher Hitchen’s book, God is Not Great, is over. A new breed of atheists and agnostics has taken over, and they realize with Nietzsche there is no Western civilization without Christianity. Speaking of the ancient world, Holland gives us a little taste of the values of that world:

The Greeks, when they captured a city, had licensed rape as a reward for valor. The Romans had stocked their households with young boys and girls, and used them as they pleased. Everyone in antiquity had taken for granted that infanticide was perfectly legitimate; that to turn the other cheek was folly; that “Nature has given the weak to be slaves.”

Which world would anyone rather live in, that or the modern world? Holland, however, doesn’t believe Christianity is the truth, but that its ideas have had a beneficial effect on Western civilization nonetheless. Maybe, but if Christianity is not the truth, which it proclaims it is all throughout the New Testament, then it’s a lie, a horrible, terrible, dirty rotten lie, and I would argue lies in the end never have beneficial effects on anything. It’s the truth of the Christian message, the risen and ascended Jesus of Nazareth, the gospel, that give it its power to transform nations.

The second thing is related to this. Back when the Covid debacle was getting started, I began listening to Christian testimonies. By this time I’ve listened to hundreds of them, and never tire of hearing how God saves his people from their sins (Matt. 1:21). I am convinced lies cannot do that, and Christianity never claims to be mere ideas, just another self-help moralistic religion. It claims a risen Savior, God come in human flesh, who died for our sins, who promised his Holy Spirit to dwell in us his reconciled people, to enable them to build the kingdom of God on earth. This is all historically falsifiable, and in 2,000 years of trying, it’s critics have not been able to do that. Rather lives continued to be transformed, all proclaiming the same message, that Jesus is their Lord and Savior, a real and palpable presence in their lives, transforming them and the societies and communities in which they live, and they give Christ all the glory. Lies do not do that.  

Worry, Fear, Doubt, and Anxiety–Repent!

Worry, Fear, Doubt, and Anxiety–Repent!

I’ve been a Christian a long time, and over all those years I’ve discovered through my struggles with sin that my greatest sin is lack of trust in God. I came to call those struggles the pain of sanctification; it’s not easy fighting against the inclinations of what Paul calls “the flesh.” Paul describes it well in Romans 7. We do what we don’t want to do, and don’t do what we want. What Winston Churchill said of Russia is true of us, at least if we’re honest with ourselves: we’re a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. What causes us to be such a conundrum to ourselves is, as Paul says, the sin living in us. Christians can relate to Paul’s frustration when he finally says, “What a wretched man I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death?” The answer is as obvious as is the struggle itself: “Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord!”

The moment we become Christians, or realize growing up we are Christians, we’ve entered into a cosmic conflict between good and evil much bigger than us. The name of the enemy of our souls, Satan, comes from the Hebrew meaning “adversary” or “accuser,” and the devil from the Greek means “Slanderer,” “false accuser,” or “defamer.” I don’t know how any of this works, but somehow as we’re in this battle with forces that literally live in our flesh, he, or his minions, are heaping abuse on us. This could be our own psychology, or our minds, tearing us down, but whatever it is, it is much bigger than just us. If we don’t counter lies with truth, we will end up fleeing from God who we’ll see as our judge, jury, and executioner. He was that, of course, but God himself in Christ chose to pay the penalty himself, all of it.

If we’re to be successful in our battle against sin, as much as is possible in this fallen body, it will come slowly over time, three steps forward, two back, with constant input from the Bible, prayer, the church, reading, and listening. As we do this, we’ll discover something very encouraging in what often discourages us: the conviction of our sin, and the desire to overcome it, is evidence God is working in our lives. A sensitive conscience is a gift from God. Jesus tells us why this is the case when as he’s encouraging his disciples before he goes away, speaks about the Holy Spirit and tells them (John 16):

8 When he comes, he will convict the world in regard to sin and righteousness and judgment.

The Holy Spirit’s job living inside of us is to convict us of sin! To, in the meaning of the word, to convince, rebuke, and reprove us.

We tend to forget this when we grapple with these forces that so confuse us. We think, why can’t this be easier? Does every Christian go through this? Surely, I must be worse than the average Christian. No, we’re all still sinners, saved, but sinners, nonetheless. Remember the Apostle Paul considered himself the foremost among sinners (I Tim. 1:15), and what he describes in Romans 7 is common among Christians, or should be. Our struggle with sin, with ourselves, is evidence God is working in our lives. No struggle means no God, so we can rejoice in it, and since perfect is never on the table we don’t have to live in guilt and shame. As Paul tells us because of God, Christ is our righteousness, sanctification, and redemption (I Cor. 1:30). That means, he’s got us covered, from justification, through life, and to our resurrection.

Our Relationship to God: Living in Trust
The purpose of life is relationship to God, our Creator. The Westminster Shorter Catechism begins with the most important question in life: “What is the chief end of man?” What’s our purpose, our telos, why are we here. When we get the answer right, it’s like putting a plug in the socket; the electricity starts to flow: “The chief end of man is to glorify God and enjoy him forever.” There is absolutely nothing as glorious, and for me mind bending, to know that God is intimately involved with every aspect of my life, every moment, every thought even before I think it, my every act, every hope, every aspiration, every joy, and yes, my every worry, fear, doubt and anxiety. The crazy thing, the truth as Paul tells us in Romans 8:28, is that everything works together for our good, and his glory. Not many things, not most things, not almost everything, but every, single, thing. I would joke with my kids as they were growing up that Paul certainly didn’t mean everything. I mean, maybe 98%, but certainly not all of it? Yes, all of it. I know, it’s hard to believe sometimes given life can be, well life, but that’s his promise to us, that we can truly enjoy him! And life. He’s for us, not against us. As Jesus said, he came to give us life abundantly, to the full (John 10:10).

If we’re truly to enter this life of enjoying God, and thus enjoying our lives, we will live by faith, not by sight. Of course, that’s not as easy as it sounds, but Christians have been pulling it off, to one degree or another, for 2,000 years. The phrase, “live by faith, not by site,” comes from the Apostle Paul in 2 Corinthians 5. He is talking about living in this body, and that while we do, we are away from the Lord, from the eternal dwelling he has prepared for us. Until then, in this body, we as he says, “we groan and are burdened.” It’s not easy, and expecting it to be ironically makes it all the harder. The key that unlocks the joy and ability to enjoy life and God and everything else, is faith, but properly understood. We modern people who live post-Enlightenment, tend to see faith as intellectual assent to something. We believe X, Y, or Z, and thus we have faith, but that’s not the idea conveyed in the Greek πίστις-pistis, for that word, nor how the New Testament normally uses it. Strong’s is helpful in giving us the more expansive, more fully human, and biblical, understanding of the word:

From peitho; persuasion, i.e. Credence; moral conviction (of religious truth, or the truthfulness of God or a religious teacher), especially reliance upon Christ for salvation; abstractly, constancy in such profession; by extension, the system of religious (Gospel) truth itself — assurance, belief, believe, faith, fidelity.

Although the word isn’t translated this way, I think the best English word that captures its meaning is trust. So, we can alter Paul’s statement a bit, that we live but trust, not by sight. That includes mental and intellectual assent, but so much more. It’s our whole being, including our emotions and will. It’s one thing to believe the bridge will carry the weight of our car as we drive over it, it’s quite another to drive over it.

Then we must ask, what’s the opposite, living by sight. I would say that means living by circumstances as if they we somehow independent of the sovereign, providential control of Almighty God. Many people, most, allow their circumstances to determine their mental and emotional state. If circumstances are to their liking, they are happy and at peace, if not, they are miserable. Christians ought not to live that way, or at least fight against it. Rather, we glorify God before others and spiritual beings as well, angels and as Paul calls the dark side, the rulers, authorities, and powers of this dark world, the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms (Eph. 6:12). One of the more challenging verses in the Bible is I Thessalonians 5:18, “Give thanks in all circumstances, for this is God’s will for you in Christ Jesus.” That doesn’t leave much wiggle room, does it.

Another verse puts this topic in perspective, one I pray often, Isaiah 26:3. The chapter is a beautiful, prophetic and eschatological picture of what God will accomplish for his people, and verse 3 speaks to how we combat worry, fear, doubt and anxiety:

You will keep in perfect peace
him whose minds is steadfast,
because he trusts in you.

If we trust in God, and are determined to have that trust, we will have perfect peace. I’m not sure I’ve ever achieved peaceful perfection, but it’s a daily aspiration. I don’t want the burden of having to try to orchestrate all the events of my life so I can be happy and peaceful. It seems a whole lot easier to trust God, to let God be God, and know that he somehow orchestrates everything in our lives for our good and his glory.

The Importance of Repentance
Over the decades I’ve been a Christian I’ve read and heard a lot, and one day I remember listening to something on my little MP3 player on a walk, and the speaker said something like, we don’t realize that fear is a sin. I think he also said, it’s worse than other sins specifically because we’re not trusting God. I don’t think I’d thought of fear as a sin before. Sometimes, of course, fear is a natural and healthy response to a threat in our environment, but whatever fear I experience, it rarely has to do with that. As I thought about this idea of fear as a sin, I realized that means we need to repent of it, and over time I realized that applied to worry and anxiety as well. I notice the commands in the New Testament by Paul and Jesus about these are just that, commands and not suggestions.

In Matthew 6, Jesus says, “Do not worry about your life,” and gives examples of food and clothing. Paul is even more emphatic. In Philippians 4 he tells us.

6 Do not be anxious about anything, but in every situation, by prayer and petition, with thanksgiving, present your requests to God. 7 And the peace of God, which transcends all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus.

Some years back a family member, a Christian, was telling me how things were not going well in her life, and she said fear of something bad happening hangs like a canopy over her head, and in my naturally sensitive way I said to her, “You need to repent!” I remember the strange look on her face, like what does that have to do with anything. At the time I was probably just really beginning to understand how sinful these thoughts and emotions can be, and was starting to make repentance for them part of my daily prayer routine. In fact, repenting of those, and praying for God’s perfect peace that transcends all understanding, are the first things I pray every morning.

Somewhere around this time I learned that Martin Luther begins his 95 Thesis that sparked the Reformation with these words about repentance:

  1. When our Lord and Master Jesus Christ said, “Repent” (Mt 4:17), he willed the entire life of believers to be one of repentance

That’s a remarkable statement if you think about it. That means 24/7 we understand we’re sinners and depend on and live in light of the cross and Christ as our Savior, our righteous, sanctification, and redemption (I Cor. 1:30). It doesn’t leave much room for self-righteousness, but a life of thanksgiving, the contrast to a life of anxiety. That’s why I always follow my repentance with thanksgiving for the infinite blessings God has poured out on my life.

We can only do this in dependence on God and his word. I recently did a post on when Jesus told us that, “Man shall not live on bread alone, but on every word that comes from the mouth of God.” If we truly desire the perfect peace, an impossible goal but to which we must all strive, it will only happen seeking God in his word and prayer. I love the promises of God in this regard throughout his word, that we find our hope and power in the word that became flesh, and in the words he’s left us in his revelation, Scripture. In Isaiah 55, God gives an invitation to “all who are thirsty,” and he promises his provision if we’ll seek him and forsake our wicked ways. Then he tells us how this can be found.

8 “For my thoughts are not your thoughts,
neither are your ways my ways,”
declares the Lord.
9 “As the heavens are higher than the earth,
so are my ways higher than your ways
and my thoughts than your thoughts.
10 As the rain and the snow
come down from heaven,
and do not return to it
without watering the earth
and making it bud and flourish,
so that it yields seed for the sower and bread for the eater,
11 so is my word that goes out from my mouth:
It will not return to me empty,
but will accomplish what I desire
and achieve the purpose for which I sent it.
12 You will go out in joy
and be led forth in peace;
the mountains and hills
will burst into song before you,
and all the trees of the field
will clap their hands.
13 Instead of the thornbush will grow the juniper,
and instead of briers the myrtle will grow.
This will be for the Lord’s renown,
for an everlasting sign,
that will endure forever.”

This promise will only finally be fulfilled in “forever,” but we can live in some approximation of that joy and peace now, in this life even as difficult as it can be. That is the power of the gospel.

Forgive Our Debts, as We Forgive Our Debtors

Forgive Our Debts, as We Forgive Our Debtors

Sometimes we’re so familiar with something we miss its obvious significance. The Lord’s Prayer is one of these things; every Christian has either recited it in church many times, or read it in the gospels, and knows how central it is to the teaching of Jesus. I was recently reminded how easy it is to miss the profundity contained in Jesus’ simple prayer at a church service at Coral Ridge Presbyterian Church. We were down visiting my best friend forever from 7th grade, Greg Luther Smith, and heard Pastor Rob  Pacienza preach about being forgiven and forgiving, and how intimately they are tied together. It was a powerful sermon, which was indicated by my taking copious notes, and I knew I had to write about it.

He broke Jesus’ message down to a typically pastoral three points:

  1. Vertical Forgiveness
  2. Horizontal Forgiveness
  3. Vertical and Horizontal Power

Basically, God forgives us, we forgive others, and there is life transforming power flowing both ways. It almost seems trite, this forgiveness. We all know the heart of the Christian religion is grace and mercy, the cross, and the love and forgiveness flowing out of it, but what makes it so profound is when it’s actually practiced and experienced in the crucible that is real life lived in a fallen world among fallen people in our fallen bodies. These are not just mere ideas that happen to work when we practice them, that we do them simply because they make life so much easier and more pleasant. We practice forgiveness because it is the very essence and foundation of our faith and the Christian religion, and makes a life of true flourishing and blessing possible. This takes us back 4,000 years to God’s calling and promise to Abram in Genesis 12:

3 I will bless those who bless you,
and whoever curses you I will curse;
and all peoples on earth
will be blessed through you.”

Given God is never in a hurry, and it would be 2,000 years before we learn how this blessing is to flow to all peoples on earth in and through Christ, in and through us his people. It would be a spiritual blessing of being reconciled to God that would have profound relational and material blessings throughout the earth. Forgiveness is central to these blessings.

Vertical Forgiveness
Pastor Rob started the sermon with a statement he remembers from his premarital counseling:

The power of forgiveness is the key ingredient to a healthy marriage.

Having celebrated our 39th wedding anniversary this past August, I could have shouted out in a less Presbyterian setting, “Amen!” This reminded me of the very first words our premarital counselor told us:

The only sinner bigger than the one you’re marrying is you.

When you understand and accept the truth of this statement, you’ll see why forgiveness is so important to a marriage and what makes it possible. This, it seems to me, is as obvious as it is difficult to practice. We’re rebellious self-centered little buggers, and we tend to believe other people, especially our spouses, are bigger sinners than we are, which of course makes forgiving them all the harder.

A lack of forgiveness is a relationship killer, any relationship. Yet how many marriages are destroyed because of a refusal to forgive. Over time in our marriage, it became apparent that forgiving my wife was a choice, and as the saying goes, it wasn’t even a choice. As a Christian I was compelled to forgive because God in Christ forgave me, and he did so when I was his enemy! What makes the cross such a powerful symbol in our lives is that forgiven people forgive, or they should. For God to be able to forgive me, and to remain just, the penalty had to be paid, and as we know that penalty is death. It seems harsh, but we don’t make the rules; we are born into them. It becomes clear to us very early in life that we live in a moral universe, where right and wrong, good and evil, exist. That means punishment and rewards are part of the deal.

Think about a child taking a toy some other child is playing with. What’s their first response? “That’s mine! Give it back!” And if the child doesn’t get it back, the mother or father might say, don’t worry about it, let the other kid have it. The response is inevitably, “But that’s not fair!” The child intuitively, viscerally, feels injustice, and that justice should be done. When obvious wrong is done, all human beings feel that justice must be done, that wrongs must be righted, that debts must be paid. God is the foundation of the moral order, and as creatures made in his image we bear the implant of the moral order in our beings. When Adam ate of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, sin and death entered the world, and forgiveness became a necessary ingredient of existence.

From the very beginning God had a plan, and we see the need for sacrifice and forgiveness revealed to us throughout the history of redemption, ultimately fulfilled in Christ. The price for sin, death, had to be paid, if man was to be reconciled to God. The legal demand exists and must be paid. Every other religion and philosophy that has ever existed agrees, that the debt must be paid, but in all of them the debt has to be paid by you! Only in Christianity was the debt paid by another, and that by the one against whom the debt was incurred, God himself in Christ. The saying, you can’t make this stuff up! applies here, literally. Human beings don’t make up a religious system where the one offended incurs the penalty of the offender, or there would not be only one religion that does that. In the made up religions, the offender pays their own penalty so justice can be done. In Christianity, by contrast, the justice is done by God for us. One of the most powerful passages of vertical forgiveness is from Colossians 2:

13 When you were dead in your sins and in the uncircumcision of your flesh, God made you alive with Christ. He forgave us all our sins, 14 having canceled the charge of our legal indebtedness, which stood against us and condemned us; he has taken it away, nailing it to the cross.

Our relationship to God, our Creator, defines everything about us, and he reconciled us to himself when we were completely powerless, dead, to do anything about it. When Jesus said it is finished on the cross, the penalty had been paid, the legal debt to God had been cancelled, the exchange took place, Christ’s righteousness for our sin. Now we are free to forgive others, to live, as Paul calls it, in the ministry of reconciliation, to transform enmity and strife into friendship, peace, and love.

Horizontal Forgiveness
The way we do this is realizing forgiven people forgive others, or they should. The vertical forgiveness we receive from God naturally flows into horizontal forgiveness for others, or it should. The most important need of the human heart is to be forgiven, to be accepted, loved and cherished as if our lives really mattered to others. On the other side, the next most important need of the human heart is to forgive, to be the kind of person who forgives others when offense is given. If we don’t, we will not only destroy the relationship, bur ourselves and others. This is what the writer to the Hebrews gets at in these verses from chapter 12:

14 Make every effort to live in peace with everyone and to be holy; without holiness no one will see the Lord. 15 See to it that no one falls short of the grace of God and that no bitter root grows up to cause trouble and defile many.

Roots grow underground, they are invisible, but without roots the tree doesn’t exist, doesn’t grow. The roots of bitterness, or unforgiveness, grow poisonous fruit, and the trouble caused in the person’s life stain or pollute or contaminate us and other people. Forgiveness, or lack thereof, is never just about the people directly involved, but many in their orbit. If we really want fruitful, flourishing, and blessed lives, we’ll live lifestyles of forgiveness. The word grace is critical to enabling such a lifestyle because, as we know, grace is unmerited favor. The other person cannot merit, or earn, forgiveness, because like God in Christ it must be freely given.

We can see how we do this from the words Jesus prays. He specifically uses the word debt for a reason, and not trespasses as Catholics read it. The idea is that when offense is given something is owed to the party offended, and forgiveness is declaring that we will not make the other person pay what they owe us. We’ll wipe the slate clean as if the debt had already been paid because it has, in Christ. Our debt was death, as Paul says, “the wages of sin.” Sin, whether against God or others, always incurs a debt, and because of Christ we get to decide what to do with it, whether we will make the other person pay for their guilt or not.

That means, the other’s repentance isn’t required before forgiveness will be granted. We simply decide because, as I said, we have no choice, to forgive. This doesn’t negate the earthly consequences of sin either. Just because I forgive someone, it doesn’t mean I have to be their best friend, or that there will not be real, harmful, material or relational consequences. These have to be negotiated with prudence and wisdom, for which we daily pray. The bottom line is that without forgiveness, we will either grow naïve or cynical, we’ll be taken advantage of and abused on the one hand, or live lives of distrust and suspicion on the other. Love expressing itself in forgiveness is the better way.

Vertical and Horizontal Power
One of the most radical and profound truths revealed to us about the nature of God in Scripture is that God is love, and in that revelation we learn that God’s love is efficacious. That means God’s love in the meaning of that word is capable of producing a desired result or effect, and because God is God, sovereign and all powerful, his love always accomplishes his desired end, which is our justification, sanctification, and redemption (I Cor. 1:30). The blessings he promised to come through Abram (Genesis 12), were accomplished in Christ, and is being fulfilled in his people. In I John 4, the Apostle is exhorting us to love one another, and he roots our ability to love others in God having first loved us. As he says in verse 19, “We love because he first loved us.”

That means we have the power, the ability and the capability, to love others, and a significant part of love is forgiveness. John tells us we have this power to love specifically because in loving us, God “sent his son to be the propitiation for our sins” (4:10). The word propitiation, what Christ accomplished on the cross, means an offering to appease or satisfy an angry, offended party. God’s wrath was fully satisfied in Christ, the debt our sin incurred, was fully paid, so that now if we become the offended party, we vicariously experience that propitiation toward others as God in Christ experienced toward us. Those who are forgiven are now able to forgive. We are no longer hostages to our pride which often gets in the way of forgiving others.

In speaking of the ministry of reconciliation in 2 Corinthians 5, Paul explains John’s point in another way, that this power, this ability is available to us because of what Christ has done for us. He says, “Christ’s love compels us” (v. 14). And because he died for us, those “who live should no longer live for themselves but for him who died for them and was raised again” (v. 15). This means as he says in the next verse, we no longer see people, literally, “according to the flesh.” The NIV says, “from a worldly point of view.” We now realize it’s no longer all about us! Just because someone wronged us, it’s not the most important thing in the world anymore. Our perspective is completely changed because everything is now viewed through the Christ lens, through forgiven to forgive.

This perspective and power available to us as God’s holy, set apart people, is especially important when we don’t want to love or forgive others. Just because we now have the ability to forgive, doesn’t mean it comes easily. Even as forgiven and redeemed sinners, we’re still self-centered sinners on this side of eternity. The beautify of Christianity, though, is that because we are rooted and established in Christ, we can each in our own feeble way, exhibit the fruit of the Spirit, which Paul tells us is, “love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control” (Gal. 5). Think about living a life filled with those things, and how glorious that would be, how glorious it is! If we compare that to the alternative, there is no comparison.

Lastly, Jesus puts his prayer in the affirmative. We are asking God to forgive our debts because we already forgive our debtors. In other words, we have no right to ask God for forgiveness if we don’t forgive others, but because we do, then we can pray with integrity, “Forgive us out debts, as we forgive our debtors.”

Is Certitude a Christian Virtue?

Is Certitude a Christian Virtue?

I’ve had a complicated relationship with certitude over my many years as a Christian. I’m reminded of what an unpleasant character trait it can be. Being certain about things is good and fine, but I’ve interacted with absolutists on Twitter/X over the last couple years who take their certainty to another level, many of them Christians. These are people so convinced they are right about topic X, they won’t stop until you agree they are in fact right and you are wrong. Nothing less than complete victory and surrender will do, it seems. Obnoxious isn’t exactly the right word for such people, but they are terribly annoying. It’s amazing how difficult it is for them to accept that not everyone will see things as they do. When it gets to be too much I say, we’ll just have to agree to disagree, and even then some of them have a hard time letting go. Maybe the reason they’re so annoying is that they remind me a bit of who I once was.

It’s a personality trait some of us struggle with, and for me the realization of that struggle started when I was 18 years old, and obviously knew it all. Knowing is a very simple thing when you’re ignorant. It’s only as your knowledge grows that you realize maybe it’s not so simple after all. It becomes increasingly obvious, or should, that the more you know, the more you realize you don’t know. Man’s knowledge, all of it, from the beginning of time until now, is a thimble full in an ocean of infinite knowledge because all knowledge comes from the mind of our infinite God, and is thus a bottomless, never ending ocean of knowledge. Why any of us think we should have absolute certainty when we know so little is a mystery, but not really. Sinners believe and do all kinds of crazy things.

Unfortunately, many sinners miss the reality of our limitations and finitude, and they truly believe absolute certainty is attainable, even desirable. For them there is no question it’s a virtue. Some of these people come across as “know it alls,” and can be as obnoxious and tiring as “know-it-alls” tend to be. Such people come on a spectrum in how it’s expressed, but it’s usually not a terribly attractive character trait. It can be difficult for such people to truly love others because as Paul warned us in I Corinthians 8:1, “knowledge puffs up while love builds up.” It doesn’t have to, but it can. The secret to allowing our knowledge to be in the service of others in love is what he says in the next verse: “The one who thinks he knows something does not yet know as he ought to know.” It seems that Paul would not be a big fan of certitude, even as certain as he could be. He understood what is far more important to know, that “whoever loves God is known by God,” as he says in verse 3. My knowledge is nothing compared to the truth that God knows me, and if that doesn’t humble us, nothing will.

I’ll get into a bit of the history of how all this came to be, but I want to explain how complicated this relationship was for me. By nature I was a dogmatic sort who wanted to be right, and I thought it was important try to convince others they should agree with me if they wanted to be right too. I didn’t realize I had this not so attractive trait until one Saturday afternoon in college. I was with some people of the campus Christian student organization I was involved with at a swap meet. The ministry leader, also named Mike, said he’d like to drive back with me to campus. Uh oh, as I would find out. He confronted me about my certitude problem, although I didn’t know that’s what it was. He told me, bluntly, that I was an unpleasant person to be around exactly because this was who I was. As I remember him putting it, he said, you always want people to agree with you, and you make them feel bad if they don’t. I do?

It was one of the most difficult, and humbling, take downs I’ve ever had in my Christian walk, but also one of the most helpful. I’ve never forgotten it, and how I recovered from the attendant emotional devastation—God! After a very dark night of the soul, in church the next morning God told me in so many words not to worry about it, but to trust him and he would help me learn how to love others. I didn’t want to love others, and told him so. It’s hard, but I knew even at that early point in my Christian life that I had no choice. The very essence of Christianity is to love others and part of the greatest commandment.

Figuring out how not to be who I naturally am has taken a lifetime of what I call the pain of sanctification. When we become Christians God begins the process in us of transformation, and while it’s a wholly supernatural process by the power of the Holy Spirit, it happens in the mundane of everyday life. The Christian life is all about him creating a truly holy people who can obey the greatest commandment to love him and love others as ourselves, something that doesn’t come easy to we self-absorbed sinners. For me, it’s only been in the last several years that I can truly not care, at all, if someone has a different perspective on something than I do. I still have extremely strong convictions about things, and I can adequately defend them. I also love getting in conversations with others about things where we disagree, if they are  truly interested in my perspective, but I no longer feel any need to try to convince them how right I am and how wrong they are, thank God!

The History of Absolute Certainty
All of this goes back to an area of study that’s been a topic of much debate for millennia, epistemology, the study of how we know what we know. As I said, our knowledge is not so simple a concept after all. It’s also fascinating to me that our faith starts with an issue arising from epistemology, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. Do not eat of that tree! They did, and our knowing thereafter became problematic and contentious. It took a long time, however, for epistemology to become an obsession for intellectuals in what we’ve come to call modern philosophy. Yes, the ancient Greeks debated and discussed it, but it wasn’t until one of my favorite whipping boys, René Descartes (1596‑1650), that knowledge began to take center stage in man’s grappling with existence. Prior to Descartes, ontology, or the study of being, was where philosophy started, which meant starting with the ground of being, or God. Now it would start with man’s knowledge, and thus man. Eventually God became superfluous.

Descartes was concerned about the growing skepticism in Europe, and as a pious Catholic he decided he had to do something about it. His approach was unique. First he would doubt everything that could be doubted, and from there decided the one thing he couldn’t doubt was his existence. In his Discourse on the Method, first published in 1637, he wrote how he came to this conclusion: “I think, therefore I am,” or as he would write in a later work the most famous words in the history of philosophy, in Latin, “cogito ergo sum.” If he was thinking, he must exist, and that he couldn’t doubt. This was the beginning of his search for absolute certainty, and how the idea such a thing was even possible entered the bloodstream of Western thinking.

R.C. Sproul in The Consequences of Ideas, writes that Descartes set up four rules that needed to be followed in the quest for truth. The first of which stated: “never accept as true anything that is not known to be true without absolute certainty.” Later in his life Descartes expanded those rules to twenty‑one, including this: “Direct your inquiries, not to what others have thought, nor to your own conjecture, but to what you can behold with clarity and deduce with certainty.” Because of Descartes, philosophers eventually came to believe that reason is the only means of knowing, as if knowing could be reduced to the laws of logic. That would be like thinking human beings can experience the world with only one of their five senses. Os Guinness in his book, In Two Minds, explains the helpful idea of limits, especially as we address the question of whether certitude is a Christian virtue:

Christianity is second to none in the place it gives to reason, but it is also second to none in keeping reason in its place. We never know the value of a thing until we know its limits. Put unlimited value on something and in the end you will exhaust it of all value. If we forget the limits of a thing, we fly in the face of reality and condemn ourselves to learn this simple ironic lesson: More without limits is less; less with limits is more.

Reason by itself, without revelation, is something like colorblindness. It can learn, apprehend, and know things, but it can never fully define these for what they are because only in Christ do all things hold together (Col. 1:17). Think of it in terms of universals and particulars, or puzzles and puzzle pieces. Without God in Christ, who is the ultimate universal, no particular can be defined in its fullness, for what God created it to be, its telos, or end. Reason alone without revelation is like muscles in the human body without tendons; there is nothing to hold everything together. All we got is puzzle pieces. But that didn’t stop people from believing the pursuit of absolute certainty is possible, even among Christians, and in my experience, maybe especially among Christians.

The subtitle of Sproul’s book says it all, “Understanding the Concepts That Shaped Our World.” Because of Descartes, reason was exalted as man’s most important faculty in the pursuit of knowledge, and the result is what we call rationalism. Not only was absolute certainty now possible, it was desirable. Finally man could fulfill what he’s longed for since the Garden, as the serpent put it, “you will be like God, knowing good and evil.” He might have said, “You, oh sovereign man, get to determine what reality is!” This refusal to accept our created nature makes perfect sense in light of what we read in Genesis 1‑3, that our Creator is God and we are not (shocking to some, I know). We learn that the fall from our esteemed created state was instigated by the temptation of wanting to be like God, to usurp his place as the one who defines reality. The insistence that we ought to have absolute certainty and can reason our way to perfect knowledge is an indication we are by nature rebels who refuse to accept that we are contingent beings. We are dependent on God, as the Apostle Paul told the Greek philosophers in Acts 17, for life, breath, and everything else, which pretty much covers it all.

Knowing, Certainty, and Finitude
This also leaves us with the most important enemy of absolute certainty—our finitude, that we are finite beings, limited in every way. That means the more we know, the more we realize we don’t know, or it should. When you’re a child your entire existence is mom and dad and your house. Then you’re exposed to your yard, and then your street. Soon you see that’s part of a town, and as you grow up you realize you’re part of a state, then a country and an entire world, then eventually part of an entire universe. You and mom and dad used to be your whole universe, now you’re a miniscule dot in it all. So it is with our knowledge.

That means the virtue is in realizing the limits to our knowledge, not thinking we have it all figured out because that’s impossible. The certainty we have about some things must always be tempered by the realization of our limits. This, I believe, is the context of the passage on knowledge in I Corinthians 8 I quoted above. Paul is telling us the answer to the question of our title, whether certitude, or absolute certainty, is a virtue—it is not. There are a lot of things I’m very certain about that intelligent people I highly respect see differently. In years past the less mature me would feel compelled to try to convince those people they were wrong and I was right. It truly bothered me they didn’t see or understand whatever it was like I did. Isn’t it obvious? How can they not see this or that or the other thing? G. K. Chesterton understood this dynamic well:

There are two kinds of people in the world: the conscious dogmatists, and the unconscious dogmatists. I have always found myself that the unconscious dogmatists were by far the most dogmatic.

The latter are the people I called absolutists above who don’t realize how unattractive and unnecessary such dogmatism is. That was the much younger me, but it still took decades to realize the wisdom of Chesterton’s statement.

I worked through all this in my journey to what I’ve come to call epistemic humility. That word comes from the Greek, epistḗm, which means knowledge. It’s where we get the word epistemology from. When we consider Paul’s caution, it’s clear from the context Paul isn’t saying that we can’t “know” things, that we can’t have some form of certainty. Only, I’m convinced, he’s saying not certainty of an absolute sort, as if we were not finite. He affirms in verse 1 that we do possess knowledge, but this knowledge becomes problematic when we become puffed up with it. In the Greek that word means arrogant, inflated, to make proud or haughty. Earlier in Corinthians, chapter 4 Paul says something apropos to this discussion:

7 For who makes you different from anyone else? What do you have that you did not receive? And if you did receive it, why do you boast as though you did not?

Does not this apply to our knowledge as well? Our knowledge can only make us haughty and arrogant if we think it’s ours, as if we possess it and did not discover it by the grace of God. That’s why the context of chapter 8 is so important. Paul is talking about food sacrificed to idols, and how those who have knowledge that idols are nothing, don’t even exist, shouldn’t be used to harm our brothers for whom it’s a problem. In other words, our knowledge and knowing should always be used in love in the service of others, not to prove them wrong, or how right we are. I know it’s shocking to some, but we could even be wrong! And of that, I am certain.

Is Jesus God? The Testimony of Scripture

Is Jesus God? The Testimony of Scripture

This has to be one of the easiest theological questions in Christianity to answer given it’s so obvious in our Bibles, at least for those God has given eyes to see. I was inspired to write this post because since we’ve lived where we do now, I’ve encountered Jehovah’s Witnesses (JWs) at our door numerous times. I never have or make the time to engage them, and decided I would write something that could help me should I ever decide to do that. I know exactly why I believe in the divinity of Christ, but it always helps me to get things down on paper to really cement them in my mind.

You’re already guessed if you don’t know that JW’s don’t believe Jesus is God. What do they believe? The Witnesses came out of a time, the 1840s, and an area many cults did, called the Burned-Over District of upstate New York. So many revivals swept through the area that eventually it became “burned over” with the exhaustion of it all. This was the time when the Erie Canal, completed in 1825, was transforming the upper Great Lakes region. As the population grew, so grew the revivalism of the Second Great Awakening, which along with liberal Christianity created numerous new religious and utopian movements, basically heretical variants of Christianity, including Mormonism, and the Millerites, out of which came the JWs.

The JWs were started by Charles Taze Russell (1852–1916), a Presbyterian who had become disillusioned with mainstream Christian doctrines like hell and the Trinity, and decided to study the Bible on his own. Out of this in 1872 he developed the International Bible Students Association, which eventually came to be called the Jehovah’s Witnesses in 1931. They can sound like Christians because they are Bible focused and mimic many orthodox beliefs, but like Russell they reject the Trinity, and distort many other orthodox doctrines. Like many cults, Russell and the JWs wanted to get back to the pure, unadulterated Christianity of the Apostles before, as they believe, it was all distorted after they died.

As we seek to defend the Trinity and the deity of Christ, it is important to understand how it developed in the early church specifically after the Apostles departed to be with Christ.

What to Make of Jesus of Nazareth
Judaism is a monotheistic religion. What came to be called the Shama is cited daily, and often multiple times a day in prayer services, by observant Jews as an affirmation of the oneness of God. It comes from Deuteronomy 6:4:

Hear, O Israel: The LORD our God, the LORD is one.

We’ll remember that the Hebrew people became a nation declaring this amidst a sea of other peoples who worshipped many gods. Israel’s God was the almighty Creator God who made all things, and he was One. When Jesus came on the scene and started doing things that were the prerogative of God only, it didn’t sit well with the monotheistic Jewish culture of the day. We can add to that Jewish Messianic expectations. In the 400 years from Malachi when the prophets ceased to speak, expectations of who the Messiah would be were all over the place. All Jews could agree on was that there would be a Messiah, a Savior king figure, and he would be a human being, exalted in some way, but still human. In fact, because of their conceptions about God they could conceive of nothing else.

Then came “the Conundrum that was Jesus,” as I title of a chapter in my book, Uninvented. What he did and said confused everybody, friend and foe alike. One of the primary reasons I believe Christianity is true is because there is no way first century Jews make up a Messiah like Jesus. I could cite examples all day, but let’s look at a few.

The healing of the paralytic (Matthew 9:1–8; Mark 2:1–12; Luke 5:17–26)
Massive crowds had come to see Jesus because word had spread that he was a great healer, so a paralyzed man was brought for him to heal. Instead Jesus did the unexpected as he always did, and he said, “Take heart, son; your sins are forgiven.” The Pharisees and teachers of the law were horrified because to them Jesus was blaspheming. They were right if Jesus wasn’t who he claimed to be because as they rightly said, only God alone can forgive sins. Then to prove he is exactly that, he heals the paralyzed man to demonstrate he did have the authority to forgive sin. To the religious leaders that made no difference. Jesus was a blasphemer and the penalty is death by stoning, which they tried to do several times but didn’t succeed—the cross was his destiny.

Jesus Calms the Storm (Matthew 8:23–27; Mark 4:36–41; John 6:16–21)
Jesus’ power over nature, including healing the sick and raising the dead, was not something the expected Messiah would do. Ironically, even though that is the case, it was exactly these things that eventually convinced his disciples he was God incarnate, God in human flesh. One of my favorite scenes in the gospels is when Jesus calms the storm on the Sea of Galilee, which is in fact a lake. We read this story in the synoptic gospels, each with a slightly different take. In Mark and Luke, Jesus tells his disciples that they need to go to the other side of the lake, so they got a boat and took off. Notice he didn’t say, let’s go to the middle of the lake and drown. As the storm comes up and the waves are breaking over the boat, that’s exactly what they thought was going to happen. And what is Jesus doing? Sleeping! Being Israel’s Messiah was exhaustive work.

Of course the disciples are terrified, and they wake up Jesus. In Mark the disciples exclaim, “Teacher, don’t you care if we drown?” That’s almost funny. In Luke and Matthew they just say, “We’re going to drown.” Uh, no we’re not! And of course Jesus says and does the unexpected, from Matthew:

26 He replied, “You of little faith, why are you so afraid?” Then he got up and rebuked the winds and the waves, and it was completely calm.

Why are we so afraid? Oh, I don’t know, we’re in the middle of the lake in the dark and there’s a furious storm, that’s why. The point Jesus is making is that since he’s with them there is no reason to be afraid. Then he does the completely unexpected: he rebukes the winds and the waves, and I imagine in a manner like they’re petulant children. Then it’s immediately calm. They are of course blown away, and Mark’s version I think captures how most people would respond.

41 They were terrified and asked each other, “Who is this? Even the wind and the waves obey him!”

Exactly! The Messiah was supposed to do great things, but not this. The implications were indeed terrifying. When Moses and Elijah and Elisha did miracles, they prayed and looked to God to do them, but not Jesus. He spoke directly to the wind and waves, and they obeyed.

Jesus Raises the Dead (Luke 7:11–17; Luke 8:40–56; John 11)
Needless to say, bringing dead people back to life was also not on the Messiah’s to-do list. The first time was a widow in the town of Nain whose only son had died. When Jesus tells the dead man to get up, and he does, the people are amazed and think Jesus is a great prophet. But when Elijah and Elisha raised the dead, they prayed to God. Jesus simply spoke to the dead person. The same thing happens with Jairus’ daughter; when he tells her to get up, she does. And the most spectacular and amazing of these events, of Jesus having power over death itself, is the raising of his friend Lazraus. The difference here, though, was that he allowed Lazarus to be dead for four days. The body was, as his sister said, already decomposing, but he tells them to roll away the stone. Then he calls out in a loud voice, “Lazarus, come forth!” And he does! A mere human Messiah doesn’t have that power.

The Sayings of Jesus
It isn’t just what Jesus did that compels us to believe he is divine, but the things he said. Not only does a normal human being not say the things he did, no Jew in the first century could have put those words in his mouth. Everything Jesus said and did to them was inconceivable, as in they could never conceive of the coming Messiah making such claims. Like his deeds, we’ll just look at a few. The first that comes to my mind comes from John 14:6. Jesus is trying to comfort his disciples as the crucifixion grows near, and tells them he is going to prepare a place for them in his Father’s house. He says they know the place where he is going, but Thomas replies that they don’t even know the way.

6 Jesus answered, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me. 7 If you really know me, you will know my Father as well. From now on, you do know him and have seen him.”

Who says things like this? Certainly not a normal human being. No other religious figure in history ever claimed to be the truth and the life because none of them were God! Then Jesus makes it clear to them what he’s saying. Philip says, “Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us.” Jesus is clearly frustrated with them, so says it straight.

9 Jesus answered: “Don’t you know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a long time? Anyone who has seen me has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’?

Jesus also claimed that he alone deserved absolute loyalty, he did, not his ideas. In Matthew 10 Jesus is preparing to send out the twelve, giving “them authority to drive out impure spirits and to heal every disease and sickness.” He is asserting the loyalty he is owed, then says this:

37 “Anyone who loves their father or mother more than me is not worthy of me; anyone who loves their son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me. 38 Whoever does not take up his cross and follow me is not worthy of me. 39 Whoever finds his life will lose it, and whoever loses his life for my sake will find it.

Who says things like this? No other religious figure in history save Jesus has come close. Then there is the cross, the most horrendous, shameful, means of torture and death ever devised by sinful man. Yet here is Jesus telling his closet followers that it is a symbol of their loyalty to him. Later in Matthew 16 he reiterates his charge to his disciples making clear what he means:

24 Then Jesus said to his disciples, “Whoever wants to be my disciple must deny himself and take up his cross and follow me. 25 For whoever wants to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for my sake will find it. 

You can imagine people hearing or discussing this saying, the cross, seriously? What does that even mean? As C.S. Lewis said, Jesus was either Lord, lunatic, or liar.

Jesus also used the Sabbath as an important teaching tool in his ministry. The Jewish religious leaders were appalled Jesus would heal on the Sabbath, and in Matthew 12 we see such a scene play out, and Jesus said something they would have considered blasphemous:

8 For the Son of Man is Lord of the Sabbath.”

They knew Jesus was referring to himself because Son of Man was a common self-designation of Jesus, even though he always used it in the third-person, and all Jews knew it was a Messianic designation coming from Daniel 7. For Jesus to say he himself was the ultimate ruler, Lord, over the Sabbath was crazy, and blasphemous, which is why they sentenced him to death.

The Jewish religious leaders understood very well what Jesus was proclaiming at his trial before the Sanhedrin. In Matthew 26 we see the seriousness of what he’s saying, and how the Jewish religious leaders took it. Jesus has been arrested and is now on trial before the Sanhedrin.

The high priest said to him, “I charge you under oath by the living God: Tell us if you are the Messiah, the Son of God.”

64 “You have said so,” Jesus replied. “But I say to all of you: From now on you will see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of the Mighty One and coming on the clouds of heaven.”

65 Then the high priest tore his clothes and said, “He has spoken blasphemy! Why do we need any more witnesses? Look, now you have heard the blasphemy. 66 What do you think?”

“He is worthy of death,” they answered.

That Jesus was condemned to death for blasphemy means everyone knew Jesus was declaring himself equal with God. Everyone who heard him say this was thinking of Daniel’s dream. In it he sees the Ancient of Days seated on his throne in what is in effect a courtroom setting of coming judgment.

13 “In my vision at night I looked, and there before me was one like a son of man, coming with the clouds of heaven. He approached the Ancient of Days and was led into his presence. 14 He was given authority, glory and sovereign power; all nations and peoples of every language worshiped him. His dominion is an everlasting dominion that will not pass away, and his kingdom is one that will never be destroyed.

I’m not sure how Jews would have processed this passage, but the Son of Man figure has all the attributes of divinity, but he is not the Ancient of Days, God himself. But however they processed it, in condemning Jesus to death for blasphemy, they are declaring him to have made himself divine, equal with God. And for that, he deserved to die.

The Historical Development of the Trinity and the Divine Jesus of the Gospels
It’s impossible for me to believe anyone could read the gospels and come away thinking they don’t present Jesus as a divine figure. Critical scholars and skeptics over the last two hundred years have done just that. They come to the text with an anti-supernatural bias and discount anything portrayed as miraculous, or discount what Jesus said and its implications. But for anyone who comes to the text without that bias, Jesus’ divinity is apparent throughout.

As most Christians know, the triune nature of God took several hundred years for the church to understand after Christ rose from the dead. Since Jesus never said, hey everybody, I’m God, it had to be inferred from his actions and words, as we saw above. The Apostles and most of the  earliest followers of “the way,” were Jews, so this was complicated and difficult to wrap their minds around. If you read Acts and the epistles, though, it’s clear they all considered Jesus God in human flesh, but it took a while through several heresies for the church to declare God Triune, which was officially done at the Council of Nicaea in 325. Movements had developed that Jesus was various things, but not as he in fact was, fully God and fully man, a mystery we call the Trinity. It was in response to these movements that the church was able to finally affirm the true nature of Jesus of Nazareth our Savior God.